Best Used Cars Under $5,000
Mobile and browser friendly version of 4Chan's list of cars under 5k.
So What Is A Good Cheap First Car For $5000 Or Less?
Chart Layout: Each segment is divided into 3 categories: Asian/Import, USDM & European unless otherwise noted! To highlight deserving vehicles the “alternates & honorable mentions” selections may not always match the nationality of the primary car. It is possible that the primary choice in one category may be historically less reliable or otherwise deficient compared to an “alternate & honorable mentions” in another category-(lette vs Corolla for example). No chart or guide can completely replace proper, needs based, detailed research into a specific vehicle!
This chart is best used as a beginners guide & general reference, not a final or absolute authority on what cars are “the best”. Sections were split into Asian/USDM/European categories in an effort to provide as large a selection of applicable cars as possible. This is to account for the diverse car market in the US, the regional availability of certain cars & buyer preference. In an attempt to keep the cars on this chart as reliable & accessible as possible for beginners & /o/ novices, vehicles older than 20 years from the time this chart was revised have been excluded.
| Sub-Compacts | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Small & economical options can be great for those who need little space !!!Note!!! Due to a lack of applicable vehicles there are no European options in this category | |||
| Honda Fit | Ford Fiesta | Toyota Yaris | |
|
Cost to Own Low----------High $, $$, $$$, $$$$, $$$$$ Fiesta: $-$$ Fit: $ IQ: $ Mirage: $ Prius C: $-$$ Rio/Accent: $ Sonic: $$ Yaris: $ |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage at Purchase |
2007-2014 100,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
2011-2018 !!!Manual Only!!! 100,000 to 150,000 depending on condition |
2007-2015 150,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Excellent amount of interior space for a car of this size. Impressive MPG's. Spirited handling. Great visibility | Great fuel economy. Top trims are loaded with features. Sporty driving dynamic. Even base engine can be exciting. | Comfortable ride, crisp handling, good MPG's. Available as a sedan or hatchback. Avoids price gouging seen in Corolla |
| Cons | Lots of road noise at highway speeds. Base models are sparse. Laggy transmission. Many find seats uncomfortable | Limited space in sedan. Early Sync system is clunky. Interior plastics share same cheap feel as in the Focus | Automatic transmission can be lethargic. Some find the seating position awkward. Options are lacking in base trims |
| Common Problem Areas & Issues |
Starter, Power Steering, Clear Coat Peeling, A/C | !!!Automatic Transmissions!!! Ford Powershift Automatic is subject to a multimillion dollar class action lawsuit, Avoid! | Clear Coat Peeling, A/C System, ABS System, Fuel Pump |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions |
Mitsubishi Mirage (2014+) Reliable hatchback that offered good MPG's & rock bottom pricing for late model examples. |
Chevy Sonic (12-16) This fun to drive hatch offers a spacious cabin & lots of features. |
Toyota Prius C (12-16) Nearly 50 EPA-combined MPG ratings. Reliable models can be had around 300k+. |
| Options can be spartan but overall good value for money. | Interior looks/feels cheap & back seat is tiny but great daily driver. | Without engine issues, great for city commuting. | |
| Sub-Compacts | |
|---|---|
| Small & economical options can be great for those who need little space !!!Note!!! Due to a lack of applicable vehicles there are no European options in this category | |
| Honda Fit | |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2007-2014 100,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Excellent amount of interior space for a car of this size. Impressive MPG's. Spirited handling. Great visibility |
| Cons | Lots of road noise at highway speeds. Base models are sparse. Laggy transmission. Many find seats uncomfortable |
| Common Problems | Starter, Power Steering, Clear Coat Peeling, A/C |
| Alternates |
Mitsubishi Mirage (2014+) Reliable hatchback that offered good MPG's & rock bottom pricing for late model examples. |
| Honorable Mentions | Options can be spartan but overall good value for money. |
| Ford Fiesta | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage |
2011-2018 !!!Manual Only!!! 100,000 to 150,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Great fuel economy. Top trims are loaded with features. Sporty driving dynamic. Even base engine can be exciting. |
| Cons | Limited space in sedan. Early Sync system is clunky. Interior plastics share same cheap feel as in the Focus |
| Common Problems | !!!Automatic Transmissions!!! Ford Powershift Automatic is subject to a multimillion dollar class action lawsuit, Avoid! |
| Alternates |
Chevy Sonic (12-16) This fun to drive hatch offers a spacious cabin & lots of features. |
| Honorable Mentions | Interior looks/feels cheap & back seat is tiny but great daily driver. |
| Toyota Yaris | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2007-2015 150,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Comfortable ride, crisp handling, good MPG's. Available as a sedan or hatchback. Avoids price gouging seen in Corolla |
| Cons | Automatic transmission can be lethargic. Some find the seating position awkward. Options are lacking in base trims |
| Common Problems | Clear Coat Peeling, A/C System, ABS System, Fuel Pump |
| Alternates |
Toyota Prius C (12-16) Nearly 50 EPA-combined MPG ratings. Reliable models can be had around 300k+. |
| Honorable Mentions | Without engine issues, great for city commuting. |
| Compact Sedans | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| For basic, reliable A to B transportation in a small 4 door car, these are the top picks for a compact sedan | |||
| Honda Civic | Ford Focus Sedan | VW Jetta | |
|
Cost to Own Low----------High $, $$, $$$, $$$$, $$$$$ Civic: $-$$ Focus: $ Jetta: $ |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage at Purchase |
2006-2014 150,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
2008-2011 & 2012-2018 !!!Manual Only!!! 100,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
2006-2015 100,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Extremely reliable, great all-rounder, available in tons of configurations, lots of aftermarket if you want to rice it | Good interior layout, decent fuel economy with nice ride quality & sharp steering. Can often be found dirt cheap | Comfortable ride paired with a good drivetrain, solid handling & lots of features. TDI drivetrain is almost unkillable |
| Cons | Lots have been badly modified, poorly cared for, or both. Lower trims can be very sparse on features. Rice Tax | Interior materials are subpar. Often missing basic features. Doesn't have competitors' reputation of quality/reliability | Gas fuel economy fairly poor in class. Interior can be tight, especially back seats, & feels cheap. Electrical Gremlins |
| Common Problem Areas & Issues |
Automatic Transmission, Poor Aftermarket Modifications, Coolant Leaks & Block cracking on pre-09 Models, Paint | !!!2012+ Automatic Transmission!!! Valve Cover Gasket, Tie-Rods & Struts, Thermostat, Door Lock Actuators, Peeling Paint | Electrical Accessories, ABS Module, Ignition Switch, Window Regulators, Factory Radio, Timing Chain & Tensioner |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions |
Toyota Corolla (07-13) Excellent engines matched with top tier build quality. Solid & spacious interior. Reputation for reliability inflates prices. |
Chevy Cruze (2011-2015) Reliable, good fuel economy & surprisingly sharp handling. Top Safety Scores. Cramped, Seats not that comfortable. |
Volvo S40 (04-12) & Volvo S60 (10-18) Great features & quality with optional AWD & turbocharged engines. Ride quality could be better. Non-turbo is sluggish. |
|
Mazda3 (04-15) Offers sharp handling & an athletic 2.5L engine. Comes as a sedan & hatchback. Snag a Mazdaspeed 3 if you can find one |
Kia Forte (10-12) & Hyundai Elantra (07-13) Korean alternatives offer good fuel economy, decent options, & affordability at the cost of "meh" quality |
BMW 3 Series (06-11) & Mercedes C Class (08-11) BMW brings more performance & Mercedes more luxury. Not DIYing means high maintenance, repair & upkeep costs |
|
| Compact Sedans | |
|---|---|
| For basic, reliable A to B transportation in a small 4 door car, these are the top picks for a compact sedan | |
| Honda Civic | |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2006-2014 150,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Extremely reliable, great all-rounder, available in tons of configurations, lots of aftermarket if you want to rice it |
| Cons | Lots have been badly modified, poorly cared for, or both. Lower trims can be very sparse on features. Rice Tax |
| Common Problems | Automatic Transmission, Poor Aftermarket Modifications, Coolant Leaks & Block cracking on pre-09 Models, Paint |
| Alternates |
Toyota Corolla (07-13) Excellent engines matched with top tier build quality. Solid & spacious interior. Reputation for reliability inflates prices. |
| Honorable Mentions |
Mazda3 (04-15) Offers sharp handling & an athletic 2.5L engine. Comes as a sedan & hatchback. Snag a Mazdaspeed 3 if you can find one |
| Ford Focus Sedan | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage |
2008-2011 & 2012-2018 !!!Manual Only!!! 100,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Good interior layout, decent fuel economy with nice ride quality & sharp steering. Can often be found dirt cheap |
| Cons | Interior materials are subpar. Often missing basic features. Doesn't have competitors' reputation of quality/reliability |
| Common Problems | !!!2012+ Automatic Transmission!!! Valve Cover Gasket, Tie-Rods & Struts, Thermostat, Door Lock Actuators, Peeling Paint |
| Alternates |
Chevy Cruze (2011-2015) Reliable, good fuel economy & surprisingly sharp handling. Top Safety Scores. Cramped, Seats not that comfortable. |
| Honorable Mentions |
Kia Forte (10-12) & Hyundai Elantra (07-13) Korean alternatives offer good fuel economy, decent options, & affordability at the cost of "meh" quality |
| VW Jetta | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2006-2015 100,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Comfortable ride paired with a good drivetrain, solid handling & lots of features. TDI drivetrain is almost unkillable |
| Cons | Gas fuel economy fairly poor in class. Interior can be tight, especially back seats, & feels cheap. Electrical Gremlins |
| Common Problems | Electrical Accessories, ABS Module, Ignition Switch, Window Regulators, Factory Radio, Timing Chain & Tensioner |
| Alternates |
Volvo S40 (04-12) & Volvo S60 (10-18) Great features & quality with optional AWD & turbocharged engines. Ride quality could be better. Non-turbo is sluggish. |
| Honorable Mentions |
BMW 3 Series (06-11) & Mercedes C Class (08-11) BMW brings more performance & Mercedes more luxury. Not DIYing means high maintenance, repair & upkeep costs |
| Coupes | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| If you want something small, coupes offer a stylish & sometimes very sporty alternative to Compacts & Sub-Compacts | |||
| Scion tC | Chevy Cobalt & Pontiac G5 | BMW 3 Series | |
|
Cost to Own Low----------High $, $$, $$$, $$$$, $$$$$ Accord & Civic: $ BMW: $$$-$$$$ CLK: $$$$ Cobalt/G5: $-$$ Eclipse: $$ G35: $$-$$$ Mustang: $$ tC: $-$$ W Body/G6: $$ |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage at Purchase |
2005-2014 100,000 to 150,000 depending on condition |
2005-2009 100,000 to 150,000 depending on condition |
2000-2008 100,000 to 150,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Great build quality, nice handling, & decent safety/luxury options available. Decent back seat and trunk space | Smooth ride coupled with sporty handling. Solid, 200+ HP 4-cylinder engine, & excellent performance value in SS trim | Blast to drive & comes as a convertible. All trims well equipped with luxury features. Best drivers car in category |
| Cons | Limited headroom up front & interior is somewhat dull. While decent, handling isn't as good as chief competitors | Cramped back seats, cheap interior plastic, & handling is numb in non-SS trim levels. SS trim can be hard to find | Can be expensive to own. Upkeep & unexpected repairs are pricey if you don't DIY. Tight rear seats & small trunk |
| Common Problem Areas & Issues |
Low Quality Aftermarket Modifications, Excessive Oil Consumption on Pre-2011 models, Sunroof | Fuel Injectors, PCM, Transmission Shifter Assembly, Front Axle Seals, Ignition switch, Heavy Key Chains | Cooling system, including Water Pump & Lines, Gaskets/seals, Rust, Electrical Accessories |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions |
Honda Accord Coupe (03-14) & Civic Coupe (06-14) Both bring practicality & solid reliability to the table. An Accord equipped with the V6 & Si Civics are both fairly quick |
Pontiac G6 (06-09) & GM W Body Cars (00-08) Includes Grand Prix & Monte Carlo coupes. You'll find nice V8's & supercharged V6's. G6 even came as a convertible |
Mercedes CLK 320/430/350/500 (00-08) Luxurious with great handling & fantastic engines. Comes as a convertible. Cramped rear seats. Not as sporty as a BMW |
|
Mitsubishi Eclipse (06-12) Powerful V6 full of torque steer with comfortable seats & interior. 4-cyl is fairly weak but looks good & actually is reliable |
V6 Ford Mustang (00-08) & V6 Chevy Camaro (00-02) V6's don't have the muscle car credentials of the V8's but both provide decent power & handling at reasonable prices |
Infiniti G35 (02-07) Great V6 engine & sporty handling all coupled with a nice, spacious interior. The 350Z's trimmed down cousin |
|
| Coupes | |
|---|---|
| If you want something small, coupes offer a stylish & sometimes very sporty alternative to Compacts & Sub-Compacts | |
| Scion tC | |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2005-2014 100,000 to 150,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Great build quality, nice handling, & decent safety/luxury options available. Decent back seat and trunk space |
| Cons | Limited headroom up front & interior is somewhat dull. While decent, handling isn't as good as chief competitors |
| Common Problems | Low Quality Aftermarket Modifications, Excessive Oil Consumption on Pre-2011 models, Sunroof |
| Alternates |
Honda Accord Coupe (03-14) & Civic Coupe (06-14) Both bring practicality & solid reliability to the table. An Accord equipped with the V6 & Si Civics are both fairly quick |
| Honorable Mentions |
Mitsubishi Eclipse (06-12) Powerful V6 full of torque steer with comfortable seats & interior. 4-cyl is fairly weak but looks good & actually is reliable |
| Chevy Cobalt & Pontiac G5 | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2005-2009 100,000 to 150,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Smooth ride coupled with sporty handling. Solid, 200+ HP 4-cylinder engine, & excellent performance value in SS trim |
| Cons | Cramped back seats, cheap interior plastic, & handling is numb in non-SS trim levels. SS trim can be hard to find |
| Common Problems | Fuel Injectors, PCM, Transmission Shifter Assembly, Front Axle Seals, Ignition switch, Heavy Key Chains |
| Alternates |
Pontiac G6 (06-09) & GM W Body Cars (00-08) Includes Grand Prix & Monte Carlo coupes. You'll find nice V8's & supercharged V6's. G6 even came as a convertible |
| Honorable Mentions |
V6 Ford Mustang (00-08) & V6 Chevy Camaro (00-02) V6's don't have the muscle car credentials of the V8's but both provide decent power & handling at reasonable prices |
| BMW 3 Series | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2000-2008 100,000 to 150,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Blast to drive & comes as a convertible. All trims well equipped with luxury features. Best drivers car in category |
| Cons | Can be expensive to own. Upkeep & unexpected repairs are pricey if you don't DIY. Tight rear seats & small trunk |
| Common Problems | Cooling system, including Water Pump & Lines, Gaskets/seals, Rust, Electrical Accessories |
| Alternates |
Mercedes CLK 320/430/350/500 (00-08) Luxurious with great handling & fantastic engines. Comes as a convertible. Cramped rear seats. Not as sporty as a BMW |
| Honorable Mentions |
Infiniti G35 (02-07) Great V6 engine & sporty handling all coupled with a nice, spacious interior. The 350Z's trimmed down cousin |
| Hatchbacks | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Practical & available in tons of configurations, these are some great options if you just have to scratch that hatchback itch | |||
| Scion xA/xB/xD | Ford Focus Hatchback | VW Golf | |
|
Cost to Own Low----------High $, $$, $$$, $$$$, $$$$$ C30: $$-$$$ C-Max: $$ CR-Z: $-$$ Element: $-$$ Focus: $$ Golf: $$-$$$ Pontiac/Matrix: $$ Rabbit: $$-$$$ Scions: $-$$ |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage at Purchase |
xA(2003-2006) xB(2003-2015) xD(2008-2014) 100,000 to 150,000 depending on condition |
2002-2007 & 2012-2018 !!!Manual Only!!! 100,000 to 150,000 depending on condition |
2000-2006 & 2010+ 100,000 to 150,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Family of solid Scion hatchbacks all offer great practicality & reliability in a variety of configurations and sizes | Good interior layout, decent fuel economy with nice ride quality & sharp steering. Can often be found dirt cheap | Fun to drive, well equipped & good build quality. Roomy Interior. Can even be found with unkillable TDI diesel engine |
| Cons | All offer only mediocre fuel economy. Interior plastic looks & feels on the cheap side. Boxy body lends to poor visibility | Interior materials are subpar. Often missing basic features. Doesn't have competitors' reputation of quality/reliability | Base engine is fairly mediocre, handling suffers from high curb weight, neglected examples can turn into money pits |
| Common Problem Areas & Issues |
Low Quality Aftermarket Modifications, Excessive Oil Consumption On 2008+ xD, Power Steering | !!!2012+ Automatic Transmission!!!, Valve Cover Gasket, Tie-Rods & Struts, Thermostat, Door Lock Actuators, Peeling Paint | Timing Chain, MAF Sensor, Vacuum Hoses, Ignition Switch, Water Pump, Poor Aftermarket Modifications |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions |
Honda Element (03-11) Extremely spacious interior, low load floor & removable rear seats. Available with AWD. Only seat 4 & 'meh' MPG's |
Pontiac Vibe (03-10) & Toyota Matrix (03-13) Both built on the same platform. Smooth & refined ride. Fold flat seats that actually fold flat. Can be found with AWD |
VW Rabbit (06-09) Was voted "Best Small Car" by Car & Driver upon its debut in 2006. Their final verdict: "It's all about driving pleasure" |
|
Honda CR-Z (11-16) Spiritual successor to the CRX hatchback, It mixes nimble handling, quick steering, good looks & fantastic MPG's |
Ford C-Max/C-Max Energi (13-16) Built on the Focus platform, the C-Max came as a traditional & plug-in hybrid. Quick, 40+ MPG's |
Volvo C30 (08-13) FWD, 220+ HP hatch that matches the GTI & Mini for performance but with better build quality & refinement. |
|
| Hatchbacks | |
|---|---|
| Practical & available in tons of configurations, these are some great options if you just have to scratch that hatchback itch | |
| Scion xA/xB/xD | |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage |
xA(2003-2006) xB(2003-2015) xD(2008-2014) 100,000 to 150,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Family of solid Scion hatchbacks all offer great practicality & reliability in a variety of configurations and sizes |
| Cons | All offer only mediocre fuel economy. Interior plastic looks & feels on the cheap side. Boxy body lends to poor visibility |
| Common Problems | Low Quality Aftermarket Modifications, Excessive Oil Consumption On 2008+ xD, Power Steering |
| Alternates |
Honda Element (03-11) Extremely spacious interior, low load floor & removable rear seats. Available with AWD. Only seat 4 & 'meh' MPG's |
| Honorable Mentions |
Honda CR-Z (11-16) Spiritual successor to the CRX hatchback, It mixes nimble handling, quick steering, good looks & fantastic MPG's |
| Ford Focus Hatchback | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage |
2002-2007 & 2012-2018 !!!Manual Only!!! 100,000 to 150,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Good interior layout, decent fuel economy with nice ride quality & sharp steering. Can often be found dirt cheap |
| Cons | Interior materials are subpar. Often missing basic features. Doesn't have competitors' reputation of quality/reliability |
| Common Problems | !!!2012+ Automatic Transmission!!!, Valve Cover Gasket, Tie-Rods & Struts, Thermostat, Door Lock Actuators, Peeling Paint |
| Alternates |
Pontiac Vibe (03-10) & Toyota Matrix (03-13) Both built on the same platform. Smooth & refined ride. Fold flat seats that actually fold flat. Can be found with AWD |
| Honorable Mentions |
Ford C-Max/C-Max Energi (13-16) Built on the Focus platform, the C-Max came as a traditional & plug-in hybrid. Quick, 40+ MPG's |
| VW Golf | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage |
2000-2006 & 2010+ 100,000 to 150,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Fun to drive, well equipped & good build quality. Roomy Interior. Can even be found with unkillable TDI diesel engine |
| Cons | Base engine is fairly mediocre, handling suffers from high curb weight, neglected examples can turn into money pits |
| Common Problems | Timing Chain, MAF Sensor, Vacuum Hoses, Ignition Switch, Water Pump, Poor Aftermarket Modifications |
| Alternates |
VW Rabbit (06-09) Was voted "Best Small Car" by Car & Driver upon its debut in 2006. Their final verdict: "It's all about driving pleasure" |
| Honorable Mentions |
Volvo C30 (08-13) FWD, 220+ HP hatch that matches the GTI & Mini for performance but with better build quality & refinement. |
| Mid Size & Full Size Sedans | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| These cars are great 4 door options if you want something with a little more space or features than a smaller sedan | |||
| Toyota Avalon | Ford Crown Victoria Mercury Grand Marquis |
BMW 5 Series | |
|
Cost to Own Low----------High $, $$, $$$, $$$$, $$$$$ 5 Series: $$$-$$$$ Accord/Camry: $ Avalon: $-$$ Crown Vic: $$ Fusion: $-$$ G35: $$-$$$ Impala: $$ Passat: $$-$$$ S80: $$-$$$ |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage at Purchase |
2004-2012 150,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
2003-2011 150,000 to 250,000 depending on condition |
2003-2010 100,000 to 175,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Cavernous interior with excellent ride quality. Phenomenal all-around reliability, fit & finish and lots of features | Rear-wheel drive, plenty of interior space, comfortable ride & police tested ruggedness. Cheap to run & service. | Arguably the best all-around drivers car when it comes to sedans. Great engines. Optional AWD & comes as a wagon |
| Cons | Not all that fun to drive. Light steering. Rear seats don't fold down. Need to get an XLS or Limited to get best features | Big size & lackluster MPG ratings. Interceptors will have high idle hours. Chassis tech is ancient, expect nothing sporty | Can be expensive to own. Upkeep & unexpected repairs are pricey if you don't DIY. Tight rear seats & small trunk |
| Common Problem Areas & Issues |
Excessive Oil Consumption, Rust, VSC, Cracked Dashboards, Rear Sunshade | Ignition Coils & Boots, Intake Manifold, Instrument Cluster, Air Suspension, Transmission, MAF Sensor | Water Pump, High Pressure Fuel Pump, Electrical Accessories, Fuel Injectors, Cooling System |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions |
Honda Accord (02-12) & Toyota Camry (01-12) Both offer a solid all-round sedan. Accord is slightly sportier & the Crosstour offered a wagon body with optional AWD |
Chevy Impala (06-16) A semi-luxury ride with good space all around. Cheap GM Interior. 2012 & newer models have an optional 300hp V6 |
VW Passat (07-15) Offers a balance of comfort, handling, & nice features. Lacks the overwhelming reliability of other cars in the category |
|
Infiniti G35 (02-08) Great sedan that comes in both RWD & AWD configurations. Fantastic handling & same V6 you find in the G35 coupe |
Ford Fusion & Lincoln MKZ (06-12) Smooth ride, spacious interior, sporty handling & optional AWD. Engines could use more power, average interior |
Volvo S80 (00-11) Great interior design, comfortable seats & great ride quality. Safety & crash test scores were top notch when new |
|
| Mid Size & Full Size Sedans | |
|---|---|
| These cars are great 4 door options if you want something with a little more space or features than a smaller sedan | |
| Toyota Avalon | |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2004-2012 150,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Cavernous interior with excellent ride quality. Phenomenal all-around reliability, fit & finish and lots of features |
| Cons | Not all that fun to drive. Light steering. Rear seats don't fold down. Need to get an XLS or Limited to get best features |
| Common Problems | Excessive Oil Consumption, Rust, VSC, Cracked Dashboards, Rear Sunshade |
| Alternates |
Honda Accord (02-12) & Toyota Camry (01-12) Both offer a solid all-round sedan. Accord is slightly sportier & the Crosstour offered a wagon body with optional AWD |
| Honorable Mentions |
Infiniti G35 (02-08) Great sedan that comes in both RWD & AWD configurations. Fantastic handling & same V6 you find in the G35 coupe |
| Ford Crown Victoria | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2003-2011 150,000 to 250,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Rear-wheel drive, plenty of interior space, comfortable ride & police tested ruggedness. Cheap to run & service. |
| Cons | Big size & lackluster MPG ratings. Interceptors will have high idle hours. Chassis tech is ancient, expect nothing sporty |
| Common Problems | Ignition Coils & Boots, Intake Manifold, Instrument Cluster, Air Suspension, Transmission, MAF Sensor |
| Alternates |
Chevy Impala (06-16) A semi-luxury ride with good space all around. Cheap GM Interior. 2012 & newer models have an optional 300hp V6 |
| Honorable Mentions |
Ford Fusion & Lincoln MKZ (06-12) Smooth ride, spacious interior, sporty handling & optional AWD. Engines could use more power, average interior |
| BMW 5 Series | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2003-2010 100,000 to 175,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Arguably the best all-around drivers car when it comes to sedans. Great engines. Optional AWD & comes as a wagon |
| Cons | Can be expensive to own. Upkeep & unexpected repairs are pricey if you don't DIY. Tight rear seats & small trunk |
| Common Problems | Water Pump, High Pressure Fuel Pump, Electrical Accessories, Fuel Injectors, Cooling System |
| Alternates |
VW Passat (07-15) Offers a balance of comfort, handling, & nice features. Lacks the overwhelming reliability of other cars in the category |
| Honorable Mentions |
Volvo S80 (00-11) Great interior design, comfortable seats & great ride quality. Safety & crash test scores were top notch when new |
| Wagons | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Need a car that's extremely practical? Or to move lots of stuff or cart around more than 4 people? Something good in bad weather? Look here | |||
| Subaru Outback & Forester | Ford Flex | Volvo V50 & V70 | |
|
Cost to Own Low----------High $, $$, $$$, $$$$, $$$$$ Flex: $$$ Forester: $$ $$$ Jetta: $$-$$$ Magnum: $$-$$$ Outback: $$-$$$ Soul: $$ X & Freestyle: $$$ V50 & V70: $$-$$$ |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage at Purchase |
2000-2014(Outback) & 2000-2016(Forester) 100,00 to 200,000 depending on condition |
2009-2014 100,000 to 175,000 depending on condition |
2005-2011(V50) & 2000-2010(V70) 150,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | More cargo space than most competing CUV's. Fantastic all-around visibility. Top tier crash test scores. AWD standard | Nimble handling. Sliding rear doors & an easy access third row. Only seats 6. Not as feature rich as a traditional minivan | Superbly comfortable. Tons of cargo space & features. Great safety ratings. Optional rear facing third-row & turbo engines |
| Cons | Not all that agile. Numb steering. Base model trims are rather spartan & higher level trims have poorly laid out controls | Somewhat sluggish transmission. Focus on space for people means not as much cargo space as some minivans or CUV's | Weak NA engines that return average fuel economy. V70's handling is only mediocre. V50 can have an overly firm ride |
| Common Problem Areas & Issues |
Automatic Transmission, AWD System/Differentials. Electrical Accessories, Excessive Oil Consumption | Water Pump Leaking, Oil Leaking, Fuel Pump, Turbo, Electrical Accessories, Power Steering Pump | Transmission Failure, PCV System, Rear Main Seal, Instrument Panel Wiring, Fuel Pump Housing Leaking |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions |
Kia Soul (10-16) Not a traditional wagons but it has tons of passenger space. Loads of features, Good safety scores. Mediocre cargo space |
Ford Freestyle (05-07) & Ford Taurus X (08-09) What happens when you make a wagon out of a Ford Explorer. Hard to find, but spacious, comfortable & safe |
Dodge Magnum (05-08) Roomy interior. Optional AWD. Muscle car feel in a wagon body style if you can snag a V8. Low budget Interior & meh V6 |
|
VW Jetta Sportwagen (11-14) Based on the Golf. Tons of space, upscale interior, & a nice ride. Dieselgate TDI's have great MPG's If you can find one |
Mazda 5 (06-15) High quality cabin for an American vehicle. Near luxury ride quality. Great turbo engine. Tons of features & optional AWD |
Cars From Other Sections (See Original Listings) Mercedes C & E Class, BMW 3 & 5 Series, Subaru Impreza, VW Passat, Accord Crosstour-(MY 11-12) & Cadillac CTS |
|
| Wagons | |
|---|---|
| Need a car that's extremely practical? Or to move lots of stuff or cart around more than 4 people? Something good in bad weather? Look here | |
| Subaru Outback & Forester | |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2000-2014(Outback) & 2000-2016(Forester) 100,00 to 200,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | More cargo space than most competing CUV's. Fantastic all-around visibility. Top tier crash test scores. AWD standard |
| Cons | Not all that agile. Numb steering. Base model trims are rather spartan & higher level trims have poorly laid out controls |
| Common Problems | Automatic Transmission, AWD System/Differentials. Electrical Accessories, Excessive Oil Consumption |
| Alternates |
Kia Soul (10-16) Not a traditional wagons but it has tons of passenger space. Loads of features, Good safety scores. Mediocre cargo space |
| Honorable Mentions |
Ford Freestyle (05-07) & Ford Taurus X (08-09) What happens when you make a wagon out of a Ford Explorer. Hard to find, but spacious, comfortable & safe |
| Ford Flex | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2009-2014 100,000 to 175,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Nimble handling. Sliding rear doors & an easy access third row. Only seats 6. Not as feature rich as a traditional minivan |
| Cons | Somewhat sluggish transmission. Focus on space for people means not as much cargo space as some minivans or CUV's |
| Common Problems | Water Pump Leaking, Oil Leaking, Fuel Pump, Turbo, Electrical Accessories, Power Steering Pump |
| Alternates |
Dodge Magnum (05-08) Roomy interior. Optional AWD. Muscle car feel in a wagon body style if you can snag a V8. Low budget Interior & meh V6 |
| Honorable Mentions |
VW Jetta Sportwagen (11-14) Based on the Golf. Tons of space, upscale interior, & a nice ride. Dieselgate TDI's have great MPG's If you can find one |
| Volvo V50 & V70 | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2005-2011(V50) & 2000-2010(V70) 150,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Superbly comfortable. Tons of cargo space & features. Great safety ratings. Optional rear facing third-row & turbo engines |
| Cons | Weak NA engines that return average fuel economy. V70's handling is only mediocre. V50 can have an overly firm ride |
| Common Problems | Transmission Failure, PCV System, Rear Main Seal, Instrument Panel Wiring, Fuel Pump Housing Leaking |
| Alternates |
Mazda 5 (06-15) High quality cabin for an American vehicle. Near luxury ride quality. Great turbo engine. Tons of features & optional AWD |
| Honorable Mentions |
Cars From Other Sections (See Original Listings) Mercedes C & E Class, BMW 3 & 5 Series, Subaru Impreza, VW Passat, Accord Crosstour-(MY 11-12) & Cadillac CTS |
| Luxury Cars | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Maybe you are looking to get the most luxurious, classy ride you can get for your dollar? Start looking here, but fair warning, these rides can be expensive to maintain! | |||
| Lexus LS 430 | Cadillac CTS | Mercedes E Class | |
|
Cost to Own Low----------High $, $$, $$$, $$$$, $$$$$ A6: $$$-$$$$ CTS: $$$-$$$$ E Class: $$$-$$$$ GS & ES: $$ Genesis: $$-$$$ LS 430: $$ MKS: $$-$$$ TL & RL: $$ Town Car: $$-$$$ |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage at Purchase |
2001-2006 100,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
2003-2013 100,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
2000-2009 100,000 to 175,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Fantastic ride quality, top tier build quality & reliability. Excellent array of features & options. Great V8 powerplant | Very roomy cabin with elegant design. Nimble handling. Lots of luxury features & gadgets as standard. Optional AWD. | Well balanced blend of ride quality & handling. Can be found as a sedan or wagon. Optional AWD. Several engine options |
| Cons | Lacks the sporting credentials of its European rivals. Have to deal with a V8 that still has a timing belt. Bland Interior | Interior materials & quality won't match Asian or European rivals. Surprisingly poor visibility. Mediocre Ergonomics | Upkeep, maintenance & repairs are pricey if you don't DIY. Neglected examples will have or soon develop problems. Air Suspension, Electrical Accessories, Balance Shaft Failure, Fuel Pump, Cracked and/or Bent Wheels |
| Common Problem Areas & Issues |
Leather on door panels cracking/deteriorating | Automatic Transmission, Leaking/Burning Oil, Electrical Accessories, Differentials, Interior Plastic Rotting | Peeling Paint & Chrome, Timing Belt, Electrical Accessories |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions |
Lexus GS 430 (01-07) & Lexus ES Series (01-12) Both offer fantastic ride quality & Lexus reliability & quality in a smaller package than the LS. Still not very sporty |
Lincoln Town Car (00-11) Panther Platform car with the huge amounts of interior space; huge Trunk. Ride quality described as "Nautical" |
Audi A6 (00-11) Strong V8 that can be paired with optional AWD. Cabin has excellent fit & finish. Handling doesn't match BMW 5 Series |
| Acura RL (00-08) & Acura TL (04-13) Two sedans that offer great features, excellent build quality & a nice ride, but lack V8 muscle of other cars in the class |
Lincoln MKS (09-13) Well built, roomy interior. Tons of features & gadgets come standard. Optional AWD. Soft handling & 'meh' engines |
Hyundai Genesis Sedan (08-13) Luxury features to rival an S Class with significantly cheaper running costs. Let down by mediocre interior build quality |
|
| Luxury Cars | |
|---|---|
| Maybe you are looking to get the most luxurious, classy ride you can get for your dollar? Start looking here, but fair warning, these rides can be expensive to maintain! | |
| Lexus LS 430 | |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2001-2006 100,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Fantastic ride quality, top tier build quality & reliability. Excellent array of features & options. Great V8 powerplant |
| Cons | Lacks the sporting credentials of its European rivals. Have to deal with a V8 that still has a timing belt. Bland Interior |
| Common Problems | Leather on door panels cracking/deteriorating |
| Alternates |
Lexus GS 430 (01-07) & Lexus ES Series (01-12) Both offer fantastic ride quality & Lexus reliability & quality in a smaller package than the LS. Still not very sporty |
| Honorable Mentions |
Acura RL (00-08) & Acura TL (04-13) Two sedans that offer great features, excellent build quality & a nice ride, but lack V8 muscle of other cars in the class |
| Cadillac CTS | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2003-2013 100,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Very roomy cabin with elegant design. Nimble handling. Lots of luxury features & gadgets as standard. Optional AWD. |
| Cons | Interior materials & quality won't match Asian or European rivals. Surprisingly poor visibility. Mediocre Ergonomics |
| Common Problems | Automatic Transmission, Leaking/Burning Oil, Electrical Accessories, Differentials, Interior Plastic Rotting |
| Alternates |
Lincoln Town Car (00-11) Panther Platform car with the huge amounts of interior space; huge Trunk. Ride quality described as "Nautical" |
| Honorable Mentions |
Lincoln MKS (09-13) Well built, roomy interior. Tons of features & gadgets come standard. Optional AWD. Soft handling & 'meh' engines |
| Mercedes E Class | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2000-2009 100,000 to 175,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Well balanced blend of ride quality & handling. Can be found as a sedan or wagon. Optional AWD. Several engine options |
| Cons | Upkeep, maintenance & repairs are pricey if you don't DIY. Neglected examples will have or soon develop problems. Air Suspension, Electrical Accessories, Balance Shaft Failure, Fuel Pump, Cracked and/or Bent Wheels |
| Common Problems | Peeling Paint & Chrome, Timing Belt, Electrical Accessories |
| Alternates |
Audi A6 (00-11) Strong V8 that can be paired with optional AWD. Cabin has excellent fit & finish. Handling doesn't match BMW 5 Series |
| Honorable Mentions |
Hyundai Genesis Sedan (08-13) Luxury features to rival an S Class with significantly cheaper running costs. Let down by mediocre interior build quality |
| Sports Cars & Roadsters | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Ok, so let's forget practical altogether. !!!Note!!! The RX-8 has a rotary engine, which presents unique maintenance liabilities. Please research before purchase!!! | |||
| Mazda Miata | Pontiac Solstice & Saturn Sky | Porsche Boxster | |
|
Cost to Own Low----------High Boxster: $$$$-$$$$$ Crossfire/SLK: $$$ Miata: $ MR2: $-$$ RX-8: $$-$$$$$ Solstice/Sky: $$ TT: $5-$$$ Z4: $$$-$$$$ |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage at Purchase |
2000-2008 100,000 to 175,000 depending on condition |
Solstice(2006-2010) & Sky(2007-2010) 100,000 to 175,000 depending on condition |
2000-2004 100,000 to 150,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Fantastic steering & handling characteristics. Fun to drive at any speed. Cheap to buy & operate. Tremendous aftermarket | GXP & Redline trims have good power. Both have nimble handling, great breaking & a good ride. Surprisingly roomy. | Fantastic handling, excellent engines, & plenty of power if you can score a Boxster S. Tons of features even on base trim |
| Cons | Small trunk & cabin, noisy, & not all that fast. Very few options or features. May be too impractical for some. | Complicated soft tops & cheap plastic filled interiors. Weird ergonomics. Small trunks. Base engines are kind of dull | IMS Bearing issue can be catastrophic, any potential owner should research it. Even minor issues can be crazy expensive. |
| Common Problem Areas & Issues |
Convertible Top, Valve Cover Gaskets, A/C Compressor, Clear Coat, Rust | Soft Tops, Airbags, ABS Pump, Steering Plastic, Interior Cracking, Power Steering | Intermediate Shaft Bearing, Convertible Top, Interior Electrics, Rear Main Seal |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions |
Toyota MR2 (00-05) Mid-engine design leads to extremely well balanced handling & Chassis. The harder you push the more fun it gets |
Chrysler Crossfire (04-08) Gen 1 SLK underneath. Sharp handling & comfortable ride. Numb steering. 'Meh' interior. Comes as coupe or convertible |
BMW Z4 (02-08) Fantastic Driving & chassis dynamics. Extremely refined drivetrain. Great build quality. Tons of options & features |
| Mazda RX-8 (09-11) Fantastic handling paired with an insanely smooth rotary. Apex seal failure/engine failure can be a timebomb issue |
Mercedes SLK (00-04) What the Crossfire is based on. Only comes as a PRHT convertible. Nicer interior, but PRHT causes big blind spots |
Audi TT (00-06) TT comes as a coupe or convertible & has optional AWD. Base engines are anemic & the back seat is practically useless |
|
| Sports Cars & Roadsters | |
|---|---|
| Ok, so let's forget practical altogether. !!!Note!!! The RX-8 has a rotary engine, which presents unique maintenance liabilities. Please research before purchase!!! | |
| Mazda Miata | |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2000-2008 100,000 to 175,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Fantastic steering & handling characteristics. Fun to drive at any speed. Cheap to buy & operate. Tremendous aftermarket |
| Cons | Small trunk & cabin, noisy, & not all that fast. Very few options or features. May be too impractical for some. |
| Common Problems | Convertible Top, Valve Cover Gaskets, A/C Compressor, Clear Coat, Rust |
| Alternates |
Toyota MR2 (00-05) Mid-engine design leads to extremely well balanced handling & Chassis. The harder you push the more fun it gets |
| Honorable Mentions |
Mazda RX-8 (09-11) Fantastic handling paired with an insanely smooth rotary. Apex seal failure/engine failure can be a timebomb issue |
| Pontiac Solstice & Saturn Sky | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | Solstice(2006-2010) & Sky(2007-2010) 100,000 to 175,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | GXP & Redline trims have good power. Both have nimble handling, great breaking & a good ride. Surprisingly roomy. |
| Cons | Complicated soft tops & cheap plastic filled interiors. Weird ergonomics. Small trunks. Base engines are kind of dull |
| Common Problems | Soft Tops, Airbags, ABS Pump, Steering Plastic, Interior Cracking, Power Steering |
| Alternates |
Chrysler Crossfire (04-08) Gen 1 SLK underneath. Sharp handling & comfortable ride. Numb steering. 'Meh' interior. Comes as coupe or convertible |
| Honorable Mentions |
Mercedes SLK (00-04) What the Crossfire is based on. Only comes as a PRHT convertible. Nicer interior, but PRHT causes big blind spots |
| Porsche Boxster | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2000-2004 100,000 to 150,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Fantastic handling, excellent engines, & plenty of power if you can score a Boxster S. Tons of features even on base trim |
| Cons | IMS Bearing issue can be catastrophic, any potential owner should research it. Even minor issues can be crazy expensive. |
| Common Problems | Intermediate Shaft Bearing, Convertible Top, Interior Electrics, Rear Main Seal |
| Alternates |
BMW Z4 (02-08) Fantastic Driving & chassis dynamics. Extremely refined drivetrain. Great build quality. Tons of options & features |
| Honorable Mentions |
Audi TT (00-06) TT comes as a coupe or convertible & has optional AWD. Base engines are anemic & the back seat is practically useless |
| Performance, Muscle & Tuner Cars | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether you want an import tuner, American muscle, or some European engineering, look here for cars with a little more excitement & performance | |||
| Nissan 350Z | V8 Ford Mustang | BMW 1 Series | |
|
Cost to Own Low----------High 1 Series: $$$ 350Z: $$-$$$ Camaro/Firebird: $$ Celica: $-$$ Genesis: $$-$$$ GTI: $$-$$$ IS300: $-$$ Mustang: $-$$ RSX: $-$$ |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage at Purchase |
2003-2009 125,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
2000-2009 100,000 to 150,000 depending on condition |
2008-2013 100,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Excellent handling & powerful, refined V6. Performance value for price is almost unmatched. Comes as a convertible | Easy to find & cheap to own. Comes as a convertible. Tons of aftermarket, easy to bolt on extra power & handling | BMW driving experience at its purest. Powerful engines & sports car performance with coupe practicality. -Edmunds |
| Cons | 350Z is just aging into 5k price range. Examples may be abused, neglected, need major repairs or be a salvage title | Relatively average stock handling. Mediocre plastic interior. Higher trim Cobra/SVT models suffer from price gouging | Small, cramped back seats. Some interior elements feel cheap. Expensive to own if you can't DIY service & repair |
| Common Problem Areas & Issues |
Quality Aftermarket Modifications, Peeling Clear Coat, Clutch/Transmission, Convertible Top | Air Pump, Fuel Pump, Rotting Plastic Trim, Low Quality Aftermarket Modifications, Convertible Tops | Convertible Top, Stretched Timing Chain, Blower Motor, Electrical Accessories |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions |
Acura RSX (02-06) Type-S trim has great, high-revving engine. Nimble handling & sharp steering. Becoming hard to find clean examples |
V8 Dodge Charger (06-10) Muscle car performance in a family sedan package. Heavy curb weight spoils handling. Interior is full of cheap plastic |
V8 Dodge Charger (06-10) Muscle car performance in a family sedan package. Heavy curb weight spoils handling. Interior is full of cheap plastic |
| Toyota Celica (00-05) & Lexus IS300 (01-05) Great handling & chassis on both cars. GT-S has rev happy engine. IS300 still considered one of the best tuner cars ever |
V8 Chevy Camaro & V8 Pontiac Firebird (00-02) Spectacular V8 muscle car performance at a bargain, but with a "Boy-Racer-In-Gold-Chains" image & cheap GM interior |
Hyundai Genesis Coupe (2010+) Athletic V6 engine coupled with great handling & a well optioned cabin. 2 liter turbo has strong aftermarket potential |
|
| Performance, Muscle & Tuner Cars | |
|---|---|
| Whether you want an import tuner, American muscle, or some European engineering, look here for cars with a little more excitement & performance | |
| Nissan 350Z | |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2003-2009 125,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Excellent handling & powerful, refined V6. Performance value for price is almost unmatched. Comes as a convertible |
| Cons | 350Z is just aging into 5k price range. Examples may be abused, neglected, need major repairs or be a salvage title |
| Common Problems | Quality Aftermarket Modifications, Peeling Clear Coat, Clutch/Transmission, Convertible Top |
| Alternates | Acura RSX (02-06) Type-S trim has great, high-revving engine. Nimble handling & sharp steering. Becoming hard to find clean examples |
| Honorable Mentions | Toyota Celica (00-05) & Lexus IS300 (01-05) Great handling & chassis on both cars. GT-S has rev happy engine. IS300 still considered one of the best tuner cars ever |
| V8 Ford Mustang | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2000-2009 100,000 to 150,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Easy to find & cheap to own. Comes as a convertible. Tons of aftermarket, easy to bolt on extra power & handling |
| Cons | Relatively average stock handling. Mediocre plastic interior. Higher trim Cobra/SVT models suffer from price gouging |
| Common Problems | Air Pump, Fuel Pump, Rotting Plastic Trim, Low Quality Aftermarket Modifications, Convertible Tops |
| Alternates | V8 Dodge Charger (06-10) Muscle car performance in a family sedan package. Heavy curb weight spoils handling. Interior is full of cheap plastic |
| Honorable Mentions | V8 Chevy Camaro & V8 Pontiac Firebird (00-02) Spectacular V8 muscle car performance at a bargain, but with a "Boy-Racer-In-Gold-Chains" image & cheap GM interior |
| BMW 1 Series | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2008-2013 100,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | BMW driving experience at its purest. Powerful engines & sports car performance with coupe practicality. -Edmunds |
| Cons | Small, cramped back seats. Some interior elements feel cheap. Expensive to own if you can't DIY service & repair |
| Common Problems | Convertible Top, Stretched Timing Chain, Blower Motor, Electrical Accessories |
| Alternates | V8 Dodge Charger (06-10) Muscle car performance in a family sedan package. Heavy curb weight spoils handling. Interior is full of cheap plastic |
| Honorable Mentions | Hyundai Genesis Coupe (2010+) Athletic V6 engine coupled with great handling & a well optioned cabin. 2 liter turbo has strong aftermarket potential |
| Compact SUV's & Crossovers | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Need something to tackle winter weather or just want to sit higher than a sedan? Start looking at one of these | |||
| Toyota RAV4 | Ford Escape & Mercury Mariner | VW Tiguan | |
|
Cost to Own Low----------High $, $$, $$$, $$$$, $$$$$ CR-V & RDX: $-$$ CX-5: $$-$$$ Escape & Company: $-$$ RAV4: $-$$ Tiguan: $$$-$$$$ XC60: $$-$$$ |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage at Purchase |
2005-2011 150,000 to 250,000 depending on condition |
2008-2012 100,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
2009-2014 100,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Good balance of ride quality & handling. Second row is rather roomy. Optional AWD. V6 offers good power & MPG's | Comfortable with good visibility. Decent performance with the V6 engine. Optional AWD. Jack-of-all trades SUV | Refined ride & handling. Lively turbocharged engine & optional AWD. Upscale interior compared to rivals |
| Cons | Side-hinged rear tail gate can be impractical for tall drivers. Feel the upscale. Headroom can be an issue for tall drivers | Older tech compared to it's rivals. Rear seats don't recline. Build quality & reliability won't match the RAV4 or the CR-V | Not that much cargo space. Fuel economy is mediocre. Turbo is outmatched by competitor's V6. Requires premium gas |
| Common Problem Areas & Issues |
Excessive Oil Consumption, Steering Assembly/Power Steering Lines, Paint, Rust | Transmission Failure, Power Steering Failure, Oil Leak, Throttle Body & Cable, Rust-(!Especially in Rust Belt States!) | Timing Chain Tensioner, Plastic Intake Manifold failure, Oil Leak, Water Pump Failure, Electrical Accessories |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions |
Honda CR-V (02-11) & Acura RDX (07-12) Good handling, simple well designed interior & plenty of cargo space. Hampered by a weak engine & lots of road noise |
Volvo XC60 (10-12) Built on the Ford EUCD platform-(the Mondeo in Europe)-it is Volvo's best selling vehicle since it's 2009 introduction |
Mazda CX-5 (2013+) Just starting to age into this price bracket. Most engaging vehicle to drive in this segment. Voted best used SUV in 2013 |
| Compact SUV's & Crossovers | |
|---|---|
| Need something to tackle winter weather or just want to sit higher than a sedan? Start looking at one of these | |
| Toyota RAV4 | |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2005-2011 150,000 to 250,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Good balance of ride quality & handling. Second row is rather roomy. Optional AWD. V6 offers good power & MPG's |
| Cons | Side-hinged rear tail gate can be impractical for tall drivers. Feel the upscale. Headroom can be an issue for tall drivers |
| Common Problems | Excessive Oil Consumption, Steering Assembly/Power Steering Lines, Paint, Rust |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions | Honda CR-V (02-11) & Acura RDX (07-12) Good handling, simple well designed interior & plenty of cargo space. Hampered by a weak engine & lots of road noise |
| Ford Escape & Mercury Mariner | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2008-2012 100,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Comfortable with good visibility. Decent performance with the V6 engine. Optional AWD. Jack-of-all trades SUV |
| Cons | Older tech compared to it's rivals. Rear seats don't recline. Build quality & reliability won't match the RAV4 or the CR-V |
| Common Problems | Transmission Failure, Power Steering Failure, Oil Leak, Throttle Body & Cable, Rust-(!Especially in Rust Belt States!) |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions | Volvo XC60 (10-12) Built on the Ford EUCD platform-(the Mondeo in Europe)-it is Volvo's best selling vehicle since it's 2009 introduction |
| VW Tiguan | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2009-2014 100,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Refined ride & handling. Lively turbocharged engine & optional AWD. Upscale interior compared to rivals |
| Cons | Not that much cargo space. Fuel economy is mediocre. Turbo is outmatched by competitor's V6. Requires premium gas |
| Common Problems | Timing Chain Tensioner, Plastic Intake Manifold failure, Oil Leak, Water Pump Failure, Electrical Accessories |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions | Honda CR-V (02-11) & Acura RDX (07-12) Good handling, simple well designed interior & plenty of cargo space. Hampered by a weak engine & lots of road noise |
| Mid-Size SUV's & Crossovers | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Want something that offers more comfort, towing power & people moving capacity than a compact? These guys will do the job, albeit at the expense of fuel economy | |||
| Toyota Highlander | Ford Explorer | Volvo XC90 | |
|
Cost to Own Low----------High Edge: $$-$$$ Explorer: $$-$$$ Highlander: $$-$$$ M Class: $$$ Pilot & MDX: $$ RX Series: $$ Venza: $$-$$$ Volvo XC90: $$$ X5: $$$$ |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage at Purchase |
2001-2010 150,000 to 250,000 depending on condition |
2006-2010 150,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
2003-2012 100,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | K platform vehicles loaded with features & a ride more like a sedan than an SUV. Reputation for reliability is unmatched | Can be found in a plethora of trims & configurations. V6 is great & so is the ride quality & comfort for a truck based SUV | Bank vault safety paired with a high quality interior, tons of cargo space & a very smooth ride. Great turbo engines. |
| Cons | Lack the power of other competitors in class. No third row option. In certain conditions the ride may be too soft | Poor fuel economy. Low grade interior materials, especially in base trims. Lacks build quality of Asian or Euro competitors | Fuel mileage isn't great. Base engines are underpowered for SUV's weight. Base trims can be fairly spartan on features |
| Common Problem Areas & Issues |
Dashboard Cracking, Interior Accessories, Oil Leaks, Rack & Pinion Leaking, Paint Peeling | Transmission Failure, Radiator Leaking, Water Pump Failure, Rough Idling, Interior Plastic Rotting/Breaking, Ball Joints | Transmission Failure, Electrical Accessories & Systems, Fuel Pump, Airbag Control Module |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions |
Honda Pilot (03-11) & Acura MDX (01-11) Based on the same platform, both can be optioned with a 3rd row, AWD, rear seat entertainment & a locking rear diff |
Ford Edge & Lincoln MKX (07-14) Built to fit between the Escape & the Explorer, the Edge/MKX brings a roomy cabin, comfortable ride & lots of options |
BMW X5 (00-13) & Mercedes M Class (00-11) Luxury features & a car like ride are a hallmark of both. 1st Gen ML's come with a selectable low-range transfer case |
| Mid-Size SUV's & Crossovers | |
|---|---|
| Want something that offers more comfort, towing power & people moving capacity than a compact? These guys will do the job, albeit at the expense of fuel economy | |
| Toyota Highlander | |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2001-2010 150,000 to 250,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | K platform vehicles loaded with features & a ride more like a sedan than an SUV. Reputation for reliability is unmatched |
| Cons | Lack the power of other competitors in class. No third row option. In certain conditions the ride may be too soft |
| Common Problems | Dashboard Cracking, Interior Accessories, Oil Leaks, Rack & Pinion Leaking, Paint Peeling |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions | Honda Pilot (03-11) & Acura MDX (01-11) Based on the same platform, both can be optioned with a 3rd row, AWD, rear seat entertainment & a locking rear diff |
| Ford Explorer | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2006-2010 150,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Can be found in a plethora of trims & configurations. V6 is great & so is the ride quality & comfort for a truck based SUV |
| Cons | Poor fuel economy. Low grade interior materials, especially in base trims. Lacks build quality of Asian or Euro competitors |
| Common Problems | Transmission Failure, Radiator Leaking, Water Pump Failure, Rough Idling, Interior Plastic Rotting/Breaking, Ball Joints |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions | Ford Edge & Lincoln MKX (07-14) Built to fit between the Escape & the Explorer, the Edge/MKX brings a roomy cabin, comfortable ride & lots of options |
| Volvo XC90 | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2003-2012 100,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Bank vault safety paired with a high quality interior, tons of cargo space & a very smooth ride. Great turbo engines. |
| Cons | Fuel mileage isn't great. Base engines are underpowered for SUV's weight. Base trims can be fairly spartan on features |
| Common Problems | Transmission Failure, Electrical Accessories & Systems, Fuel Pump, Airbag Control Module |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions | BMW X5 (00-13) & Mercedes M Class (00-11) Luxury features & a car like ride are a hallmark of both. 1st Gen ML's come with a selectable low-range transfer case |
| Full-Size SUV's & Crossovers | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Need a land yacht to haul 7+ people & their stuff? Look here. !!!Note!!! Due to a large selection of applicable USDM vehicles, European options have been excluded | |||
| Toyota Sequoia | Chevy Tahoe & GMC Yukon & Cadillac Escalade SWB | Ford Expedition & Lincoln Navigator | |
|
Cost to Own Low----------High Armada: $$-$$$ Excursion: $$$-$$$$ Expedition XL/Max: Expedition: $$-$$$ Sequoia: $$ $$$ Suburban & Company: $$$-5$$$ Tahoe: $$-$$$ |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage at Purchase |
2001-2007 150,000 to 250,000 depending on condition & drivetrain |
2000-2010 150,000 to 250,000 depending on condition & drivetrain |
2003-20012 150,000 to 250,000 depending on condition & drivetrain |
| Pros | Refined drivetrain & surprisingly agile handling for a big SUV. Comfortable cabin. Near legendary reputation for reliability. | Solid, well built interior, smooth V8 & near luxury ride quality. Comfortable cabin. Tons of features. Seats up to 9 | Above average handling for size & weight. Roomy third row. Decent towing capacity for an SUV. Comfortably seats up to 8 |
| Cons | Reputation for reliability leads to extreme price gouging. Even trucks with 200,000+ miles can command a high price | 3rd row doesn't fold flat. Heavy curb weight dulls handling & acceleration. Suspension may be too floaty/soft for some | Even for a big SUV, fuel suffers when terrible gas mileage & low grade interior is outshined by rivals. Harsh ride on rough roads |
| Common Problem Areas & Issues |
VSC/Traction Control, ABS System, Transmission Failure, Rust/Frame Rot | Excessive Oil Consumption, Interior Plastic Cracking/Rotting, Stabilitrak, BCM Failure, Water In Doors | Blown Out Spark Plugs, Transmission Failure, Rust, Peeling Clear Coat, Interior Electrics & Accessories |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions |
Nissan Armada (04-12) Roomy in all 3 rows of seating. Capable off-road & 9000+ pound tow rating. Cabin materials are slightly low rent |
Chevy Suburban/GMC Yukon XL/Escalade EXT-ESV (00-10) The bigger brothers to the Tahoe & Yukon. Choice of V8 engines. Seating & cargo space for 9. Optional quadrasteer |
Ford Excursion (00-05) & Expedition EL/MAX (07-12) Bigger brothers to the Expedition & Navigator. Excursion was based on the F-250 & had an optional diesel powerplant |
| Full-Size SUV's & Crossovers | |
|---|---|
| Need a land yacht to haul 7+ people & their stuff? Look here. !!!Note!!! Due to a large selection of applicable USDM vehicles, European options have been excluded | |
| Toyota Sequoia | |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2001-2007 150,000 to 250,000 depending on condition & drivetrain |
| Pros | Refined drivetrain & surprisingly agile handling for a big SUV. Comfortable cabin. Near legendary reputation for reliability. |
| Cons | Reputation for reliability leads to extreme price gouging. Even trucks with 200,000+ miles can command a high price |
| Common Problems | VSC/Traction Control, ABS System, Transmission Failure, Rust/Frame Rot |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions | Nissan Armada (04-12) Roomy in all 3 rows of seating. Capable off-road & 9000+ pound tow rating. Cabin materials are slightly low rent |
| Chevy Tahoe & GMC Yukon & Cadillac Escalade SWB | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2000-2010 150,000 to 250,000 depending on condition & drivetrain |
| Pros | Solid, well built interior, smooth V8 & near luxury ride quality. Comfortable cabin. Tons of features. Seats up to 9 |
| Cons | 3rd row doesn't fold flat. Heavy curb weight dulls handling & acceleration. Suspension may be too floaty/soft for some |
| Common Problems | Excessive Oil Consumption, Interior Plastic Cracking/Rotting, Stabilitrak, BCM Failure, Water In Doors |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions | Chevy Suburban/GMC Yukon XL/Escalade EXT-ESV (00-10) The bigger brothers to the Tahoe & Yukon. Choice of V8 engines. Seating & cargo space for 9. Optional quadrasteer |
| Ford Expedition & Lincoln Navigator | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2003-2012 150,000 to 250,000 depending on condition & drivetrain |
| Pros | Above average handling for size & weight. Roomy third row. Decent towing capacity for an SUV. Comfortably seats up to 8 |
| Cons | Even for a big SUV, fuel suffers when terrible gas mileage & low grade interior is outshined by rivals. Harsh ride on rough roads |
| Common Problems | Blown Out Spark Plugs, Transmission Failure, Rust, Peeling Clear Coat, Interior Electrics & Accessories |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions | Ford Excursion (00-05) & Expedition EL/MAX (07-12) Bigger brothers to the Expedition & Navigator. Excursion was based on the F-250 & had an optional diesel powerplant |
| Compact Trucks | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Looking for a compact pickup? Start here. !!!Note!!! Due to a lack of applicable vehicles there are no European options in this category | |||
| Toyota Tacoma | Ford Ranger | Chevy S-10 | |
|
Cost to Own Low----------High B-Series: $-$$ Frontier: $ Ranger: $-$$ S-10: $-$$ Sonoma: $-$$ Tacoma: $ |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage at Purchase |
2000-2004 150,000 to 250,000 depending on condition |
2000-2011 150,000 to 250,000 depending on drivetrain & condition |
2000-2004 150,000 to 250,000 depending on drivetrain & condition |
| Pros | Competent off-road, multiple configurations & unmatched reliability. Comes paired with 3 excellent engine choices | Can be mixed & matched with tons of trim levels, engines & cab/bed configurations. FX4 trims make great off-roaders | Nimble & affordable with a torquey V6 and fuel efficient 14. ZR2 package is fantastic for off-roaders. Crew or single cab. |
| Cons | Reputation for reliability leads to extreme price gouging, even trucks in terrible condition may command a high price. | OHC V6's suffered reliability issues early on. Later models lack many modern features & amenities. Base engine is weak | Spotty build quality & typical low rent USDM interior filled with cheap plastic. Seating position may be too low for some |
| Common Problem Areas & Issues |
!!Rust & Frame Rot!!-(Issue so severe it resulted in 15 year corrosion warranty for these models), Front Suspension | Timing Chain, Rear Differential, OHC V6's only, Rust, Transmission Failure, Early IAC Valve | ABS Brakes, Rust, Transmission Failure, Interior Plastic Cracking/Rotting, Heater Core |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions |
Nissan Frontier (00-04) The Frontier offers many of the same attractive qualities as the Tacoma without the same degree of price gouging |
Mazda B Series (00-10) A Mazda version of the Ranger. Built on the same platform & from the same parts bin. Reference pros/cons of the Ranger |
GMC Sonoma (00-04) A GMC version of the S-10. Built on the same platform & from the same parts bin. Reference pros/cons of the S-10 |
| Compact Trucks | |
|---|---|
| Looking for a compact pickup? Start here. !!!Note!!! Due to a lack of applicable vehicles there are no European options in this category | |
| Toyota Tacoma | |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2000-2004 150,000 to 250,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Competent off-road, multiple configurations & unmatched reliability. Comes paired with 3 excellent engine choices |
| Cons | Reputation for reliability leads to extreme price gouging, even trucks in terrible condition may command a high price. |
| Common Problems | !!Rust & Frame Rot!!-(Issue so severe it resulted in 15 year corrosion warranty for these models), Front Suspension |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions | Nissan Frontier (00-04) The Frontier offers many of the same attractive qualities as the Tacoma without the same degree of price gouging |
| Ford Ranger | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2000-2011 150,000 to 250,000 depending on drivetrain & condition |
| Pros | Can be mixed & matched with tons of trim levels, engines & cab/bed configurations. FX4 trims make great off-roaders |
| Cons | OHC V6's suffered reliability issues early on. Later models lack many modern features & amenities. Base engine is weak |
| Common Problems | Timing Chain, Rear Differential, OHC V6's only, Rust, Transmission Failure, Early IAC Valve |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions | Mazda B Series (00-10) A Mazda version of the Ranger. Built on the same platform & from the same parts bin. Reference pros/cons of the Ranger |
| Chevy S-10 | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2000-2004 150,000 to 250,000 depending on drivetrain & condition |
| Pros | Nimble & affordable with a torquey V6 and fuel efficient 14. ZR2 package is fantastic for off-roaders. Crew or single cab. |
| Cons | Spotty build quality & typical low rent USDM interior filled with cheap plastic. Seating position may be too low for some |
| Common Problems | ABS Brakes, Rust, Transmission Failure, Interior Plastic Cracking/Rotting, Heater Core |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions | GMC Sonoma (00-04) A GMC version of the S-10. Built on the same platform & from the same parts bin. Reference pros/cons of the S-10 |
| Mid-Size Trucks | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Looking for a Mid-Size Truck? Start here. !!!Note!!! Due to a lack of applicable vehicles there are no European options in this category | |||
| Toyota Tacoma | Dodge Dakota | Honda Ridgeline | |
|
Cost to Own Low----------High Canyon: $$-$$$ Colorado, i-Series & Dakota: $$ Frontier: $-$$ Ridgeline: $$-$$$ Sport Trac: $$ $$$ Tacoma: $-$$ |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage at Purchase |
2005-2010 150,000 to 250,000 depending on condition & drivetrain |
2000-2011 150,000 to 250,000 depending on condition & drivetrain |
2006-2014 150,000 to 250,000 depending on condition & drivetrain |
| Pros | Upgraded to a mid-size truck in 2005, still carries a reputation for unmatched reliability & great off-road performance | Tons of cool interior storage spaces. Strong V8 matched with best-in-class towing capacity from '05+. Comfortable seats | Agile, car-like handling in a truck body & a comfortable cabin. Tons of storage space & cool cargo management features |
| Cons | Reputation for reliability leads to extreme price gouging, even trucks in terrible condition may command a high price. | Typical low-grade USDM interior. Limited choice of body styles/configurations. V8's return terrible gas mileage | Only 1 V6 engine & 1 body style available. Lackluster off-roading & towing capabilities compared to competition |
| Common Problem Areas & Issues |
Peeling Paint, Rust/Frame Rot, Interior Accessories | Oil Sludge, Brake Master Cylinder, Blower Motor, Oil Pump, Paint & Peeling Clear Coat | Instrument Cluster, Fuel Injectors, Engine Tapping/Misfire |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions |
Nissan Frontier (05-14) The Frontier offers many of the same attractive qualities as the Tacoma without the same degree of price gouging |
Chevy Colorado & GMC Canyon (04-12) Contemporary reviews ranked the GM twins behind the Dakota, but it's still a solid & affordable mid-size option |
Explorer Sport Trac (01-10) A truck platform based on the Explorer SUV. Nice balance of ride & handling, tons of functional storage compartments |
| Mid-Size Trucks | |
|---|---|
| Looking for a Mid-Size Truck? Start here. !!!Note!!! Due to a lack of applicable vehicles there are no European options in this category | |
| Toyota Tacoma | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2005-2010 150,000 to 250,000 depending on condition & drivetrain |
| Pros | Upgraded to a mid-size truck in 2005, still carries a reputation for unmatched reliability & great off-road performance |
| Cons | Reputation for reliability leads to extreme price gouging, even trucks in terrible condition may command a high price. |
| Common Problems | Peeling Paint, Rust/Frame Rot, Interior Accessories |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions | Nissan Frontier (05-14) The Frontier offers many of the same attractive qualities as the Tacoma without the same degree of price gouging |
| Dodge Dakota | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2000-2011 150,000 to 250,000 depending on condition & drivetrain |
| Pros | Tons of cool interior storage spaces. Strong V8 matched with best-in-class towing capacity from '05+. Comfortable seats |
| Cons | Typical low-grade USDM interior. Limited choice of body styles/configurations. V8's return terrible gas mileage |
| Common Problems | Oil Sludge, Brake Master Cylinder, Blower Motor, Oil Pump, Paint & Peeling Clear Coat |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions | Chevy Colorado & GMC Canyon (04-12) Contemporary reviews ranked the GM twins behind the Dakota, but it's still a solid & affordable mid-size option |
| Honda Ridgeline | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2006-2014 150,000 to 250,000 depending on condition & drivetrain |
| Pros | Agile, car-like handling in a truck body & a comfortable cabin. Tons of storage space & cool cargo management features |
| Cons | Only 1 V6 engine & 1 body style available. Lackluster off-roading & towing capabilities compared to competition |
| Common Problems | Instrument Cluster, Fuel Injectors, Engine Tapping/Misfire |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions | Explorer Sport Trac (01-10) A truck platform based on the Explorer SUV. Nice balance of ride & handling, tons of functional storage compartments |
| Full-Size SUV's & Crossovers | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Need a land yacht to haul 7+ people & their stuff? Look here. !!!Note!!! Due to a large selection of applicable USDM vehicles, European options have been excluded | |||
| Toyota Sequoia | Chevy Tahoe & GMC Yukon & Cadillac Escalade SWB | Ford Expedition & Lincoln Navigator | |
|
Cost to Own Low----------High Armada: $$-$$$ Excursion: $$$-$$$$ Expedition XL/Max: Expedition: $$-$$$ Sequoia: $$ $$$ Suburban & Company: $$$-5$$$ Tahoe: $$-$$$ |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage at Purchase |
2001-2007 150,000 to 250,000 depending on condition & drivetrain |
2000-2010 150,000 to 250,000 depending on condition & drivetrain |
2003-20012 150,000 to 250,000 depending on condition & drivetrain |
| Pros | Refined drivetrain & surprisingly agile handling for a big SUV. Comfortable cabin. Near legendary reputation for reliability. | Solid, well built interior, smooth V8 & near luxury ride quality. Comfortable cabin. Tons of features. Seats up to 9 | Above average handling for size & weight. Roomy third row. Decent towing capacity for an SUV. Comfortably seats up to 8 |
| Cons | Reputation for reliability leads to extreme price gouging. Even trucks with 200,000+ miles can command a high price | 3rd row doesn't fold flat. Heavy curb weight dulls handling & acceleration. Suspension may be too floaty/soft for some | Even for a big SUV, fuel suffers when terrible gas mileage & low grade interior is outshined by rivals. Harsh ride on rough roads |
| Common Problem Areas & Issues |
VSC/Traction Control, ABS System, Transmission Failure, Rust/Frame Rot | Excessive Oil Consumption, Interior Plastic Cracking/Rotting, Stabilitrak, BCM Failure, Water In Doors | Blown Out Spark Plugs, Transmission Failure, Rust, Peeling Clear Coat, Interior Electrics & Accessories |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions |
Nissan Armada (04-12) Roomy in all 3 rows of seating. Capable off-road & 9000+ pound tow rating. Cabin materials are slightly low rent |
Chevy Suburban/GMC Yukon XL/Escalade EXT-ESV (00-10) The bigger brothers to the Tahoe & Yukon. Choice of V8 engines. Seating & cargo space for 9. Optional quadrasteer |
Ford Excursion (00-05) & Expedition EL/MAX (07-12) Bigger brothers to the Expedition & Navigator. Excursion was based on the F-250 & had an optional diesel powerplant |
| Full-Size SUV's & Crossovers | |
|---|---|
| Need a land yacht to haul 7+ people & their stuff? Look here. !!!Note!!! Due to a large selection of applicable USDM vehicles, European options have been excluded | |
| Toyota Sequoia | |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2001-2007 150,000 to 250,000 depending on condition & drivetrain |
| Pros | Refined drivetrain & surprisingly agile handling for a big SUV. Comfortable cabin. Near legendary reputation for reliability. |
| Cons | Reputation for reliability leads to extreme price gouging. Even trucks with 200,000+ miles can command a high price |
| Common Problems | VSC/Traction Control, ABS System, Transmission Failure, Rust/Frame Rot |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions | Nissan Armada (04-12) Roomy in all 3 rows of seating. Capable off-road & 9000+ pound tow rating. Cabin materials are slightly low rent |
| Chevy Tahoe & GMC Yukon & Cadillac Escalade SWB | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2000-2010 150,000 to 250,000 depending on condition & drivetrain |
| Pros | Solid, well built interior, smooth V8 & near luxury ride quality. Comfortable cabin. Tons of features. Seats up to 9 |
| Cons | 3rd row doesn't fold flat. Heavy curb weight dulls handling & acceleration. Suspension may be too floaty/soft for some |
| Common Problems | Excessive Oil Consumption, Interior Plastic Cracking/Rotting, Stabilitrak, BCM Failure, Water In Doors |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions | Chevy Suburban/GMC Yukon XL/Escalade EXT-ESV (00-10) The bigger brothers to the Tahoe & Yukon. Choice of V8 engines. Seating & cargo space for 9. Optional quadrasteer |
| Ford Expedition & Lincoln Navigator | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2003-2012 150,000 to 250,000 depending on condition & drivetrain |
| Pros | Above average handling for size & weight. Roomy third row. Decent towing capacity for an SUV. Comfortably seats up to 8 |
| Cons | Even for a big SUV, fuel suffers when terrible gas mileage & low grade interior is outshined by rivals. Harsh ride on rough roads |
| Common Problems | Blown Out Spark Plugs, Transmission Failure, Rust, Peeling Clear Coat, Interior Electrics & Accessories |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions | Ford Excursion (00-05) & Expedition EL/MAX (07-12) Bigger brothers to the Expedition & Navigator. Excursion was based on the F-250 & had an optional diesel powerplant |
| Off-Roaders | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Looking for a great factory off-roader or a good base for an off-road build? !!!Note!!! Due to a lack of applicable vehicles there are no European options in this category | |||
| Toyota 4Runner (4x4 Only) | Jeep Wrangler TJ | Any Of The Listed Trucks Above | |
|
Cost to Own Low----------High Blazer: $$-$$$ Cherokee XJ: $$ Trucks & SUV's: $$$ Wrangler: $$-$$$ Xterra: $$ |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage at Purchase |
2000-2008 150,000 to 250,000 depending on condition & drivetrain |
150,000 to 250,000 depending on condition & drivetrain | Reference the Years & Mileage listed in the Trucks sections |
| Pros | Refined on the road but retains fantastic off-road capability. Comfortable with a tons of standard options. Strong Engines | Arguable the best factory off-roader you can buy. Simple, rugged & reliable. Huge aftermarket allows tons of potential | Many trucks have capable off-road trims. Expansive truck aftermarket makes it easy to build your own off-roader |
| Cons | Reputation for reliability leads to extreme price gouging. Even trucks in terrible condition may command a high price | Near Toyota levels of price gouging. Few options. Steering slow. Suspension is bouncy & ill-suited for city driving | Any problem already listed for a specific truck. Off-road oriented trims can command a premium. Mods aren't free |
| Common Problem Areas & Issues |
Peeling Paint, Rust/Frame Rot, Interior Accessories | Soft Top Leaking/Rotting, 'Death Wobble' in Suspension, Blower Motor, Oil Pump Drive Assembly | Anything Already Posted For Listed Trucks, Low Quality Aftermarket Modifications |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions |
Nissan Xterra (00-15) One of the most powerful V6's in its class, above average factory off-road ability. Tons of potential with some mods |
Jeep Cherokee XJ (00-01) & Chevy Blazer ZR2 (00-05) Mediocre build quality, but with a little modification these compact SUV's can be turned into formidable off-roaders |
Many Of The Listed SUV's Above (See Original Listings) Similar to trucks, many of the SUV's listed are competent off-road or can be turned into capable off-roaders fairly easily |
| Off-Roaders | |
|---|---|
| Looking for a great factory off-roader or a good base for an off-road build? !!!Note!!! Due to a lack of applicable vehicles there are no European options in this category | |
| Toyota 4Runner (4x4 Only) | |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2000-2008 150,000 to 250,000 depending on condition & drivetrain |
| Pros | Refined on the road but retains fantastic off-road capability. Comfortable with a tons of standard options. Strong Engines |
| Cons | Reputation for reliability leads to extreme price gouging. Even trucks in terrible condition may command a high price |
| Common Problems | Peeling Paint, Rust/Frame Rot, Interior Accessories |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions | Nissan Xterra (00-15) One of the most powerful V6's in its class, above average factory off-road ability. Tons of potential with some mods |
| Jeep Wrangler TJ | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 150,000 to 250,000 depending on condition & drivetrain |
| Pros | Arguable the best factory off-roader you can buy. Simple, rugged & reliable. Huge aftermarket allows tons of potential |
| Cons | Near Toyota levels of price gouging. Few options. Steering slow. Suspension is bouncy & ill-suited for city driving |
| Common Problems | Soft Top Leaking/Rotting, 'Death Wobble' in Suspension, Blower Motor, Oil Pump Drive Assembly |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions | Jeep Cherokee XJ (00-01) & Chevy Blazer ZR2 (00-05) Mediocre build quality, but with a little modification these compact SUV's can be turned into formidable off-roaders |
| Any Of The Listed Trucks Above | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | Reference the Years & Mileage listed in the Trucks sections |
| Pros | Many trucks have capable off-road trims. Expansive truck aftermarket makes it easy to build your own off-roader |
| Cons | Any problem already listed for a specific truck. Off-road oriented trims can command a premium. Mods aren't free |
| Common Problems | Anything Already Posted For Listed Trucks, Low Quality Aftermarket Modifications |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions | Many Of The Listed SUV's Above (See Original Listings) Similar to trucks, many of the SUV's listed are competent off-road or can be turned into capable off-roaders fairly easily |
| Vans & Minivans | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Because sometimes you just need a Van !!!Note!!! Due to a large selection of applicable USDM vehicles, European options have been excluded | |||
| Honda Odyssey | Chrysler Town & Country | Ford Transit & Transit Connect | |
|
Cost to Own Low----------High Freestar: $-$$ Monterey: $-$$ Odyssey: $$ Savana/Express: $$ Sienna: $$ T&C: $-$$$ Transit: $$ |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage at Purchase |
2000-2010 100,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
2001-2014 100,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
2010-2017 100,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Tons of space, great safety ratings, & lots of available options. Newer models had a great V6 and fold flat 3rd row | Stow 'n Go seats let you fold away 2nd & 3rd row for a flat floor. Smooth and quiet driving dynamic. Nice V6 engine | Can be configured or customized for any job you can imagine. Tons of options & interior space. Good fuel economy. |
| Cons | Honda badge - price inflation. Older models had sluggish transmissions & were underpowered even for a minivan | Build quality can be suspect. Interior in base trim models will feel very "budget". Numb steering to match vague handling | Limited payload & towing capacity. Turbo engine only on short wheelbase model. Passenger van 2nd row doesn't slide |
| Common Problem Areas & Issues |
Automatic Transmission, EGR Valve, Emissions system, Power Sliding Doors, Main Blower Motor | Transmission Failure, Interior Plastic Cracking/Rotting, Excessive Oil Consumption, TIPM, Electrical Accessories | Transmission failure, Misfires/Sparkplugs, Main Wiring Harness |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions |
Toyota Sienna (03-09) Based on the Toyota K platform. Safe, reliable, refined & with fold flat rear seat. Can be found with optional AWD |
Ford Freestar & Mercury Monterey (04-07) Good safety features & crash test scores. Less refined & lacks options of the competition, but can be found dirt cheap |
GMC Savana & Chevy Express (03-14) V8 engines, multiple wheelbases, low grade plastics, huge interiors & even optional AWD. Configuration & interior options |
| ans & Minivans | |
|---|---|
| Because sometimes you just need a Van !!!Note!!! Due to a large selection of applicable USDM vehicles, European options have been excluded | |
| Honda Odyssey | |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2000-2010 100,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Tons of space, great safety ratings, & lots of available options. Newer models had a great V6 and fold flat 3rd row |
| Cons | Honda badge - price inflation. Older models had sluggish transmissions & were underpowered even for a minivan |
| Common Problems | Automatic Transmission, EGR Valve, Emissions system, Power Sliding Doors, Main Blower Motor |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions | Toyota Sienna (03-09) Based on the Toyota K platform. Safe, reliable, refined & with fold flat rear seat. Can be found with optional AWD |
| Chrysler Town & Country | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2001-2014 100,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Stow 'n Go seats let you fold away 2nd & 3rd row for a flat floor. Smooth and quiet driving dynamic. Nice V6 engine |
| Cons | Build quality can be suspect. Interior in base trim models will feel very "budget". Numb steering to match vague handling |
| Common Problems | Transmission Failure, Interior Plastic Cracking/Rotting, Excessive Oil Consumption, TIPM, Electrical Accessories |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions | Ford Freestar & Mercury Monterey (04-07) Good safety features & crash test scores. Less refined & lacks options of the competition, but can be found dirt cheap |
| Ford Transit & Transit Connect | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2010-2017 100,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | Can be configured or customized for any job you can imagine. Tons of options & interior space. Good fuel economy. |
| Cons | Limited payload & towing capacity. Turbo engine only on short wheelbase model. Passenger van 2nd row doesn't slide |
| Common Problems | Transmission failure, Misfires/Sparkplugs, Main Wiring Harness |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions | GMC Savana & Chevy Express (03-14) V8 engines, multiple wheelbases, low grade plastics, huge interiors & even optional AWD. Configuration & interior options |
| Special Snowflakes: Want One? Do Your Research! | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| While interesting & fun to drive, these cars may be harder to find, unreliable, expensive to maintain, difficult to service for /o/ beginners or ANY combination of the 4! | |||
| Subaru Impreza WRX | Dodge Neon SRT-4 | Saab 9-2X/9-3/9-5 | |
|
Cost to Own Low----------High All-Saab's: $$-$$$$ Baja: $$-$$$ Caliber: $$ C30: $$-$$$ Neon: $$-$$$ PT Cruiser: $$ WRX: $$$ |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage at Purchase |
2000-2007 125,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
2003-2005 100,000 to 175,000 depending on condition |
9-2X(2005-2006) 9-3(2000-2011) 9-5(2000-2011) 100,000 to 175,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | AWD comes standard. Can be found as a sedan or wagon. Excellent handling coupled with a fantastic turbo engine | 230hp turbocharged with huge potential for cheap aftermarket power gains. Makings of a great sleeper car | All fun to drive. 9-2X is an Impreza underneath. Convertibles, wagons & AWD options available. Some come with 300+ HP |
| Cons | Most WRX's at this price point will have been heavily abused/neglected or have major mechanical problems | For 5k most examples will have been thrashed to pieces and/or been poorly modified. It's still a Neon underneath | Owning a dead Swedish brand means parts & service can be a headache. Earlier models not as refined as later cars |
| Common Problem Areas & Issues |
Poor Aftermarket Modifications, Engine Mounts, Air Bags/SRS System, Clutch, Differentials | Poor Aftermarket Modifications, Oil Leaks, Rust, Electrical Accessories, Interior Plastics Cracking & Rotting | ABS Module, Excessive Oil Consumption, ECM Failure, Hard Starts/Valve Wear, Water Pump, Convertible Tops |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions |
Subaru Baja (03-06) Can't decide if you want a Jeep or Impreza? Get the Baja. Tons of room for any number & style of aftermarket builds |
V8 Chrysler 300 (05-13) Built on retired Mercedes platforms & parts. Easy to score 340+ horsepower V8's, 5.7L has huge aftermarket potential |
Fiat 500 (12-16) Very Spacious for a small hatchback. Great MPG's with a manual. 500 Abarths are right on the cusp of the 5k budget |
| Special Snowflakes: Want One? Do Your Research! | |
|---|---|
| While interesting & fun to drive, these cars may be harder to find, unreliable, expensive to maintain, difficult to service for /o/ beginners or ANY combination of the 4! | |
| Subaru Impreza WRX | |
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2000-2007 125,000 to 200,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | AWD comes standard. Can be found as a sedan or wagon. Excellent handling coupled with a fantastic turbo engine |
| Cons | Most WRX's at this price point will have been heavily abused/neglected or have major mechanical problems |
| Common Problems | Poor Aftermarket Modifications, Engine Mounts, Air Bags/SRS System, Clutch, Differentials |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions | Subaru Baja (03-06) Can't decide if you want a Jeep or Impreza? Get the Baja. Tons of room for any number & style of aftermarket builds |
| Dodge Neon SRT-4 | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 2003-2005 100,000 to 175,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | 230hp turbocharged with huge potential for cheap aftermarket power gains. Makings of a great sleeper car |
| Cons | For 5k most examples will have been thrashed to pieces and/or been poorly modified. It's still a Neon underneath |
| Common Problems | Poor Aftermarket Modifications, Oil Leaks, Rust, Electrical Accessories, Interior Plastics Cracking & Rotting |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions | V8 Chrysler 300 (05-13) Built on retired Mercedes platforms & parts. Easy to score 340+ horsepower V8's, 5.7L has huge aftermarket potential |
| Saab 9-2X/9-3/9-5 | |
|---|---|
|
|
|
| Years & Max Mileage | 9-2X(2005-2006) 9-3(2000-2011) 9-5(2000-2011) 100,000 to 175,000 depending on condition |
| Pros | All fun to drive. 9-2X is an Impreza underneath. Convertibles, wagons & AWD options available. Some come with 300+ HP |
| Cons | Owning a dead Swedish brand means parts & service can be a headache. Earlier models not as refined as later cars |
| Common Problems | ABS Module, Excessive Oil Consumption, ECM Failure, Hard Starts/Valve Wear, Water Pump, Convertible Tops |
| Alternates & Honorable Mentions | Fiat 500 (12-16) Very Spacious for a small hatchback. Great MPG's with a manual. 500 Abarths are right on the cusp of the 5k budget |